A plain-English breakdown of the fees Brooklyn landlords pay, what each one covers, and how to spot the costs hidden in the fine print.
Published October 25, 2026 · River Management LLC
Most property managers charge a monthly management fee that is a percentage of the rent they collect. The percentage varies by company, by the rent level and by the type of property. Higher rents and larger buildings often qualify for a lower percentage, while a single apartment with a lower rent is usually priced higher.
That monthly percentage is only part of what you will pay, so it should never be the only number you compare.
Ask each company to write down your total cost for the first year on the same example. For a unit renting at a monthly figure you choose, have them list the leasing fee, the monthly fees, the renewal fee, inspection fees and any markup on repairs. The company with the lowest percentage is not always the cheapest once everything is added up.
We publish our fees on one page. There are no hidden fees for landlords or tenants, and no upcharge on maintenance: repairs are billed at actual cost. You can see the plans and rates on our pricing page, and learn more about managing a rental in Brooklyn and New York City.
Imagine two companies quoting the same Brooklyn apartment. Company A has a lower monthly percentage but charges a placement fee, a renewal fee and adds a markup to every repair. Company B has a slightly higher monthly percentage and charges nothing else. Put both into one table:
Add the four lines together for each company. The “cheaper” percentage can easily turn out to be the more expensive option once the extras are counted, especially on older buildings where repairs are frequent.
It depends on the agreement. When the fee is a percentage of rent collected, there is normally no monthly management fee in a month when no rent is collected. Always confirm this in writing.
Management fees are generally treated as a rental business expense, but tax rules depend on your situation. Ask your accountant.
Sometimes. Owners with several units or higher rents often qualify for better rates. It is also worth negotiating the other fees, not only the monthly percentage.
Compare the total first-year cost for the same example rent, including every fee and any repair markup, rather than comparing only the monthly percentage.
Thinking about management for your property? Get a free rental analysis and a clear, no-surprises proposal. Contact us or call (347) 770-0052.