A step-by-step checklist for screening applicants fairly and consistently, so you place reliable residents.
Published November 9, 2026 · River Management LLC
A good resident pays on time, treats the home with care and stays. A poor placement can cost months of rent, repairs and stress. Careful, consistent screening is the best protection you have. Use this checklist.
Write down your criteria before you start and apply them to every applicant. Fair housing laws protect people from discrimination based on protected characteristics, and local rules can add more protections, such as lawful source of income. A consistent written standard protects your applicants and you. If you are unsure what applies, confirm it with a qualified professional or an experienced property manager.
Screening takes time and care, and it is a core part of what we do. Learn how we place residents on our services page, or request a free rental analysis.
Save every application, report and note about each applicant, along with the reason for your decision. If you ever decline an applicant, a written record of your standard criteria is the best way to show that you treated everyone the same.
Verify identity, income and employment, review the credit report, check rental history with previous landlords, and review background and eviction records as the law allows.
Many landlords require annual income that is a set multiple of the monthly rent. Set a standard in writing and apply it to everyone. Local practices vary.
You can decline applicants who do not meet your written, consistent criteria. You may not discriminate on legally protected grounds, so confirm what applies in your area.
A manager brings consistent criteria, access to screening tools and experience spotting red flags, which can reduce risk and save you time.
Thinking about management for your property? Get a free rental analysis and a clear, no-surprises proposal. Contact us or call (347) 770-0052.